Proton Pass vs 1Password (2026): Aliases, Sharing and Cost
A practical, documentation-based comparison of Proton Pass and 1Password, without invented scores or a universal winner.
Updated November 2026Reviewed by StaySecureHub Editorial TeamEditorial review
Choose by workflow, not an invented score. Proton Pass offers a permanent free tier and integrated email aliases. 1Password is a paid option with personal and family accounts, Travel Mode and a documented Fastmail integration.
This comparison uses provider documentation checked on November 2, 2026; it is not a new hands-on usability or security test.
| Decision | Proton Pass | 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Free access | Permanent Free tier; 10 aliases and up to three integrated 2FA items | 14-day personal trial; no permanent free tier |
| Email aliases | Built in; unlimited aliases on Plus | Masked Email integration requires a Fastmail account |
| Household option | Pass Family: up to six users | Families: up to five users on the published base plan |
| Security approach | End-to-end encrypted vaults and open-source apps | End-to-end encrypted vaults with account password and Secret Key |
| Cost to compare | Free; Plus $2.99/month equivalent, $35.88 per 12 months | Individual $2.99/month first year; $3.99/month regular, billed yearly |
Privacy and security trade-offs
Open application code gives Proton Pass an inspectable client implementation. 1Password publishes security documentation, but it is not an open-source password manager. Neither model removes the need to secure devices and recovery information.
Price and sharing
Compare the full annual charge, user allowance, sharing controls and renewal terms. Proton's family allowance differs from 1Password's base family plan; do not confuse users with devices. A Fastmail account is a separate requirement for the 1Password alias integration.
Which should you choose?
Consider Proton Pass if free access and integrated aliases are your priorities. Consider 1Password if its documented sharing and Travel Mode features fit your household. Ease of use depends on your devices and habits; try the relevant workflow rather than treating this as a measured usability ranking.
Read the Proton Pass review and 1Password review, or compare Proton Pass with Bitwarden.
Affiliate disclosure: we may earn a commission if you subscribe through our Proton Pass link, without determining this comparison. Check Proton Pass plans. Confirm current prices and renewal terms with the provider.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has a permanent free plan?
Proton Pass has a Free tier. 1Password offers a 14-day trial for personal plans, rather than a permanent free tier.
Can both products create email aliases?
Proton Pass includes aliases directly, with plan limits. 1Password documents Masked Email integration with a separate Fastmail account. Compare the combined requirements and cost.